Literary Critique of The Square Root of Pi…

 

The Square Root of Pi… is a poignant, introspective novel that blends memoir-like personal narrative with philosophical musings and a thriller-esque plot revolving around grief, justice, and the human quest for meaning in an irrational world. Published in Kindle format, this work draws heavily from the author's background as a pediatric surgeon, artist, and writer, creating a meta-fictional layer where the protagonist's life mirrors aspects of Lugo's own biography. The story unfolds through a first-person perspective, beginning with quirky, humorous reflections on everyday absurdities and escalating into a raw exploration of profound loss. At its core, the novel uses the mathematical concept of the square root of pi—an irrational, infinite number—as a metaphor for life's unpredictability, unresolved pain, and the futility of seeking perfect closure.

 

Plot and Structure

The narrative is non-linear, weaving between the protagonist's present-day ruminations and flashbacks to his past. It opens with the narrator obsessing over calculating the square root of pi while in the bathroom (a scene that sets a tone of irreverent humor), interspersed with vignettes about his widowed life, a persistent neighbor, and mundane frustrations like social media or reheated sandwiches. This establishes a stream-of-consciousness style that feels intimate and confessional.

The plot pivots dramatically when the narrator recounts the tragic death of his wife and young daughter in a car accident caused by a drunk driver. The story then shifts into a courtroom drama, detailing the trial where the defendant is acquitted due to technicalities (e.g., lack of a blood alcohol test). Devastated, the narrator retreats to rural isolation to plot revenge: pushing the defendant off a high-rise building. However, while abroad in Colombia promoting his book The Shadow of Fear, he learns the defendant has committed suicide, robbing him of his vendetta. The novel resolves with the narrator grappling with guilt, ultimately finding catharsis through writing this very story.

Structurally, the book is divided into chapters (I through X), but it feels more like a collage of memories, philosophical detours, and emotional outbursts. This fragmented approach mirrors the theme of irrationality, though it can occasionally disrupt pacing, making some sections feel meandering before snapping back to the central conflict.

 

Themes

Lugo excels at layering profound themes beneath a deceptively casual surface. The titular square root of pi symbolizes life's inherent chaos: an infinite, non-repeating decimal that defies resolution, much like grief or justice. The narrator's obsession with solving it "naturally" (without calculators) reflects his struggle to make sense of tragedy without artificial aids like revenge or legal systems.

Grief and loss dominate, portrayed not as a linear process but as an all-consuming void. The narrator's vivid descriptions of his wife's beauty, their intimate moments, and his daughter's innocence heighten the emotional stakes, making the accident's aftermath visceral. Justice versus revenge is another key tension: the acquittal exposes the flaws in human law, pushing the narrator toward vigilantism, only for fate (or pi's irrationality) to intervene.

Other motifs include the absurdity of modern life (social media, consumerism, artificial beauty standards), the redemptive power of art and writing, and the circle as a symbol of eternal love and cycles (birth, death, forgiveness). The novel doesn't shy away from politically incorrect observations, such as critiques of contemporary beauty trends or societal stupidity, which are substantiated through the narrator's wry, experienced voice.

 

Style and Language

Lugo's prose is conversational and reflective, blending humor, eroticism, and tragedy in a way that feels authentically human. Early chapters employ light-hearted, absurd anecdotes (e.g., the "criolla" bathroom philosophy or the neighbor's fruit offerings as metaphors for temptation) to contrast the later darkness, creating emotional whiplash that underscores life's unpredictability. The language is direct, with short sentences during intense moments and longer, meandering ones for philosophical digressions.

Strengths in style include vivid sensory details: the smell of rum, the warmth of a child's embrace, or the crash's imagined sounds. Erotic scenes are explicit yet tender, emphasizing emotional connection over sensationalism. However, the frequent shifts between humor and sorrow can feel uneven, and some repetitions (e.g., pi metaphors) risk diluting their impact. Grammatical quirks and occasional awkward phrasing (possibly from translation or self-publishing) slightly mar the flow, but they add to the raw, unpolished authenticity.

 

Characters

The narrator is the novel's beating heart—a flawed, intellectual everyman whose grief evolves from obsession to reluctant acceptance. His voice is compelling, blending self-deprecating humor with raw vulnerability. The wife and daughter are idealized yet humanized through flashbacks: the wife as a fashion-savvy healer, the daughter as a clever, adventurous child. Their deaths feel earned, not exploitative, amplifying the narrator's pain.

The defendant is a tragic foil: a grieving widower whose depression leads to negligence. Lugo humanizes him through internal monologues, avoiding a one-dimensional villain, which adds moral complexity. Secondary figures (e.g., the neighbor, Mother Oña the nun) provide comic relief or symbolic depth, though some feel underdeveloped.

 

Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths lie in the novel's emotional authenticity and innovative use of mathematics as metaphor. Lugo's medical background infuses realistic details into scenes of trauma and death, while his artistic side shines in descriptions of painting and writing as catharsis. The meta-elements—where the narrator writes the book we read—create a satisfying loop, reinforcing themes of creation amid destruction. It's a bold, unapologetic exploration of dark themes, unafraid to confront taboo subjects like revenge fantasies or explicit intimacy.

Weaknesses include pacing issues: the early humorous sections meander, delaying the central plot, and the trial scenes can feel procedural. Some descriptions (e.g., the wife's physical attributes) border on objectification, potentially alienating readers. The philosophical tangents, while insightful, sometimes overshadow character development. As a self-published work, it could benefit from tighter editing to refine repetitions and polish prose.

 

Conclusion

The Square Root of Pi… is a compelling, if imperfect, meditation on grief's irrationality and the search for meaning in chaos. Lugo crafts a narrative that is deeply personal, blending the mundane with the profound in a way that resonates long after the final page. It's not a traditional thriller or memoir but a hybrid that challenges readers to confront life's unresolved equations. For fans of introspective fiction like Albert Camus or Milan Kundera, infused with Latin American flair, this novel offers a unique voice. Despite its flaws, it earns a solid 4.5 out of 5 stars for its emotional bravery and metaphorical depth. If Lugo continues honing his craft, his future works could achieve even greater precision—much like solving for pi's elusive root.

 

* * * 

 

Available:  

Paperback - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DPWRXTQC

Kindle eBook - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GKYTKBHZ